Skip to main content

The future of Royals’ pitching staff hangs in the balance ahead of non-tender deadline 

Is it time to break up or do they give it another chance? 
ByMatthew Swigonski
Baltimore Orioles v Kansas City Royals
Baltimore Orioles v Kansas City Royals | Jamie Squire/GettyImages

There aren’t many nice ways to describe the performance of the Kansas City Royals’ pitching staff in 2026. Thanks to an onslaught of injuries and frustrating down years, the team allowed the fourth-most earned runs (755) in all of baseball. With the inability to keep opponents from hanging up crooked numbers on the scoreboard, the Royals struggled to win ballgames throughout the season. 

After making a blockbuster trade with the Seattle Mariners to acquire Bryce Miller and two other MLB pitchers, general manager J.J. Picollo and the rest of the Royals front office have at least shown a desire to put that rough 2026 season behind them. The Royals recently acquired relief pitcher Angel Bastardo from the Boston Red Sox for infielder Jack Pineda as well.

According to ESPN’s Jeff Passan, the Royals and pitcher Randy Dobnak have also agreed to a $1.35 million salary for the 2027 season. The move not only avoids arbitration, but it also secures one of the team’s most underrated players from this past season. While not perfect, Dobnak provided a tremendous amount of value when the Royals were in desperate times. 

Although these moves answer a lot of questions surrounding the team’s pitching staff, there is still plenty of work in front of the Royals if they intend to turn things around in 2027.  

The Royals have important decisions to make ahead of the non-tender deadline 

As the November 20 non-tender deadline inches closer, the Royals have just hours to decide the fates of pitchers like Lucas Erceg, Nate Pearson, and Anthony Gose. As we saw in 2026, pitching depth proved to be a major factor in the Royals’ downfall. But with a combined price tag of more than $5 million to retain the services of all three pitchers next season, the club could choose to wipe the slate clean and start over with a revamped pitching staff.  

With Miller and a trio of newly acquired pitchers set to join Dobnak and the rest of the Royals’ pitching staff in 2027, there may be a few impending roster cuts in the very near future. With Pearson set to earn $2 million next year, the Royals could opt to let the hard-throwing righty walk. 

Throughout his six-year big league career, Pearson has been a bit of an enigma. While his four-seamer sits in the upper 90s, he remains one of the more hittable flamethrowers in the game. The Royals could decide to save that $2 million and spend it elsewhere, especially after adding lefty Jose A. Ferrer in the Maikel Garcia deal. 

On the flip side, the Royals could see Lucas Erceg and his projected $2.3 million salary in 2027 as a worthwhile investment. After battling through his worst season in the majors, the team may view his struggles as a fixable mechanical issue. Despite having his walks per nine rate explode to 6.0 in 2026, Erceg was still among the best in the league at avoiding barrels and inducing soft contact on the ground. If he can find his 2024 form, he could be invaluable to the team. 

At $1.1 million, Gose’s contract would be a minimal hit to the team’s payroll. Gose is still somewhat of an unproven pitcher in the league, with just 45.2 innings of work in his career. And at 36 years old, he is at the tail end of his career. However, his 0.66 ERA and 0.951 WHIP in 14 games in 2026 are very tempting for the Royals to build on. 

Piccolo has already stated that he intends to err on the side of caution when it comes to spending money on the Royals’ bullpen this offseason. At the end of the day, he might not find three better pitchers at such reasonable value as Pearson, Erceg, and Gose. 

Add us as a preferred source on Google