Skip to main content

The only move J.J. Picollo can make after the Maikel Garcia blockbuster is to spend the savings

Spend, Spend, Spend!
ByBrian Burrows
Nov 7, 2023; Scottsdale, AZ, USA; Kansas City Royals general manager J.J. Picollo speaks to the media during the MLB General Manager's Meetings at Omni Scottsdale Resort & Spa. Mandatory Credit: Mark J. Rebilas-USA TODAY Sports
Nov 7, 2023; Scottsdale, AZ, USA; Kansas City Royals general manager J.J. Picollo speaks to the media during the MLB General Manager's Meetings at Omni Scottsdale Resort & Spa. Mandatory Credit: Mark J. Rebilas-USA TODAY Sports | USA TODAY Sports via Reuters Connect

The Kansas City Royals shocked the baseball world on November 18 when they completed the blockbuster trade that sent Maikel Garcia and two others to the Mariners for a three-player package that included starting pitcher Bryce Miller.

The Royals were in desperate need of pitching upgrades for 2027, and the trade got them just that. They got a starter with front-line potential in Miller, though certainly not guaranteed; another back-end-of-the-rotation arm in Logan Evans, and a potential leverage reliever in Jose A. Ferrer. The thing is, they had to sell low on former All-Star and Gold Glove-winning third baseman Maikel Garcia to get them.

The optics surrounding the deal have a lot of question marks. The Royals signed Garcia to a very team-friendly five-year extension less than a year ago. He was supposed to partner with Bobby Witt Jr. on the left side of the infield as the team grew around them. After one down season that was also hampered by injuries, he was traded. He was also traded for a starter who only has one season of pitching to his potential, which has been followed by two seasons of injuries and ups and downs.

One of the few things J.J. Picollo can do to make this trade look slightly better is use the money he is saving from the trade. While Garcia's deal was team-friendly, it also had an AAV of $11.5 million. For most teams, an All-Star-caliber player on that type of deal is chump change, but for a team in one of the smallest markets in the sport, that can limit the budget.

The Royals better spend money to upgrade the rest of the team after trading away Maikel Garcia

Miller is heading into his first year of arbitration this offseason and has a projected salary of $3.9 million for 2027. Ferrer is also heading into his first year of arbitration with a projected salary of $1.6 million. Evans won't be arb-eligible for another two seasons, and (under the current system) will make $780,000. That's a combined salary of $6.28 million. That's a savings of $5.22 million that Picollo needs to spend.

In terms of baseball contracts, $5.22 million won't get very far, and it generally can't guarantee a truly impactful upgrade. What it can do is push the budget higher to get a higher-priced free agent, though. It's highly unlikely the Royals were heading into this offseason without any money they were willing to spend. That extra $5 million could be huge if spent correctly.

Picollo hadn't given any sort of estimate as to how much the Royals were looking to spend on upgrades this offseason, but his quotes about the bullpen from the G.M. Meetings gave a little inkling as to what Kansas City could be looking at. He mentioned that they would be bargain-hunting to upgrade the bullpen.

“We have to figure out creative ways with financing and how we’re going to handle this,” Picollo told MLB.com. "Whether or not we put more money in the starting pitching or bullpen remains to be seen."

That was not what Royals fans were hoping to hear at the start of the offseason. Kansas City's budget for upgrades already seemed small this winter. Not only did this trade help address some of the rotation and bullpen concerns, as did the trade he made for Angel Bastardo the day before, but it also opened up a little budget for other moves.

Being a small market team is never easy among the big dogs, especially on the free agent front. That's why drafting and developing are so important, as proven by the Brewers and Rays. Getting Maikel Garcia to sign a long-term extension felt like such a win for the organization, and now that's undone. The only step they can take now is to utilize the savings to make more additions. Turn the salary of one impactful player into the salary of four impactful players.

Add us as a preferred source on Google