The Kansas City Royals set the hot stove alight on November 18 when they made the first blockbuster trade of the offseason, completing a six-player swap with the Seattle Mariners that saw former All-Star third baseman Maikel Garcia head to the Northwest and high-upside starting pitcher Bryce Miller come to the City of Fountains.
The deal has been a head-scratcher for many MLB analysts, both those who cover the Royals and those who cover baseball nationally. Garcia was supposed to be a franchise building block, and had signed a five-year, extremely team-friendly contract extension less than a year ago. The Royals didn't get an All-Star in return. They got a pitcher with top-of-the-rotation upside that he's only been able to tap into in spurts, a reliever coming off a down season, and a pitcher coming off Tommy John surgery.
The trade starts to make more sense after seeing what Dustin May got in free agency this offseason. On November 17, the day before the Royals-Mariners blockbuster, May got a three-year, $52.5 million contract from the Chicago White Sox. May was by no means the class of the free-agent starting pitchers; honestly, he was probably closer to the third tier of pitchers.
The 29-year-old finished the season with a 4.70 ERA, but struggled after being traded at the deadline. After signing a one-year deal with St. Louis last offseason, he had a 4.38 ERA with them, including a standout complete-game one-hitter. He was dealt to the Brewers at the deadline, where he made 10 appearances for them and had a 5.65 ERA, with more than half of his outings being less than four innings long.
While pundits have said that teams will pay for what's under the hood with pitchers, and that May still has a lot of good raw stuff, if a pitcher like that is getting $17.5 million per year, that's a bad sign for the Royals.
The Royals may have been priced out of the pitching market after one signing this offseason
Kansas City already has a majority of its guaranteed money tied up in the starting rotation. Michael Wacha and Seth Lugo will make a combined $34 million in 2027, and count for $40 million against the luxury tax. The team needs pitching upgrades for next season, but with May setting the market where he did, the Royals were likely quickly being priced out of the market for truly impactful starters.
That's why the deal for Miller starts to make more sense. While it is still hard to justify selling low on a player one year removed from an All-Star campaign that also resulted in a Gold Glove, getting back three pitchers who will instantly impact the pitching staff is hard to say no to.
Miller will slot right into the opening-day starting rotation for K.C., and Logan Evans will likely join it once he's ready to go. Jose A. Ferrer should be an impact arm in the bullpen for the entire season, too.
Finding creative ways to make meaningful upgrades is hard, especially with a limited budget. Having a lot of money tied up in just a few players makes it hard to navigate an offseason. While getting Garcia to sign a long-term deal was good on paper, being able to flip him into three usable assets and save a little money in the process is just as beneficial.
With May and the White Sox setting the benchmark for starting pitcher contracts, the Royals would really need to stretch their budget to sign a pitcher who would slot toward the top of their rotation next season. It's the unfortunate reality of a small market, but when they need to get creative with the budget, these are the moves that end up getting made.
