Royals bold trade deadline strategy will shape their offseason (for better or worse)

The idea that the Kansas City Royals are very close to becoming contenders again is not exactly new for this team. They have consistently been one of those ball clubs that seemingly put it all together in the blink of an eye before breaking it apart just as quickly. And that usually has to do with dismantling a strong yet soon-to-be pricey roster. However, the Royals ran into the exact opposite problem during this season’s trade deadline. 

With $40 million in combined salaries on the books, Michael Wacha and Seth Lugo were two of the most expensive players on the Royals’ roster in 2026. But if they were able to pitch to their full potential and guide the team to the postseason, then their salaries would have been well worth the price of admission. 

Right out of the gate this season, it became abundantly clear that the postseason probably wasn’t a realistic option. With a number of injuries and down years from trusted veteran players, the Royals had dug themselves into too deep of a hole by mid-season. So when the trade deadline rolled around, it made sense for other teams to kick the tires on Wacha and Lugo and for the Royals to pick the best deal.  

With rumors of their imminent departures swirling, it seemed like only a matter of time before Royals fans were Googling the names of newly-acquired prospects the team would get in return for the hurlers. Obviously, that never happened and Wacha and Lugo remained with the team for the entire season. For a team suffering through a failed season, it was a misfire to hold on to both pitchers for two wildly different reasons. 

The Royals needed to get the maximum value from their trade pieces 

Wacha enjoyed one of his best seasons in his 14-year career in 2026. With 4.3 bWAR in 200.2 innings pitched, he was one of the Royals' best players all year. At the trade deadline, he was perhaps the team's most attractive trade piece. With a reasonable contract and another year of team control, he was projected to be an excellent fit for a number of teams desperate for starting pitching. 

Lugo on the other hand may have been a tougher sell. While he struggled in the first half of the year and has shown signs of regression over the last two seasons, he was still capable of providing a contending team an innings eater with over a decade of MLB experience. And with another year of team control on his contract, he could have slid in as a solid addition to the back of many starting rotations. But his $23 million salary in 2027 could have been deemed too much of an investment to take on for some teams. 

With a 38-59 record at the trade deadline, it only made sense for the Royals to move each pitcher though. Wacha’s trade value may never reach the same levels again. He was also very impressive in the second half of the season, posting a 0.984 WHIP in 13 starts. But the Royals could have received a haul of high-level talent in exchange for his services. 

It seems unlikely for the team to deal him now, so he’ll head into the 2027 season as a part of a solid 1-2 punch with Noah Cameron. It’s not the worst scenario for the Royals though, since they will need a solid rotation next season. But you still can’t help but wonder what type of return that the team could have received if they opted to deal him.  

It’s a different story for Lugo. He enjoyed his only All-Star season in 2024, a key component to a Royals team that won their first postseason series in nearly a decade. But he is a pitcher who just doesn't fit the team's plans any more. His large salary could have been spent elsewhere to plug up some holes on the roster. Now his contract seems like an albatross that may hold the Royals back from building a stronger roster.   

The Royals have a very solid core of young players that could put them into position to win a lot of games over the next few seasons. With the potential of another superstar in Angeibel Gomez, there is a lot to look forward to in the Royals’ kingdom. And with every youth movement in baseball, there always needs to be some veteran presence to help guide them. 

But with a flawed roster at the moment, the team needed an opportunity to inject more talent all around. Wacha was the chance to achieve that. Meanwhile parting ways with Lugo would have given the Royals the chance to free up money to use in free agency this offseason. Now it seems unlikely that Royals GM J.J. Picollo will have the funds to pursue any significant free agent talent. 

The Royals holding onto Wacha and Lugo at the deadline was certainly a bold strategy. But the team will have a hard time justifying their willingness to run it back in 2027 if their roster is plagued with the same concerns as this season. 

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow