Today may go down as one of the most important dates in video game history. With the highly, highly, highly anticipated release of Grand Theft Auto VI, millions of employees and students across the globe will suddenly come down with an incurable case of the four-day cold. As a video game franchise centered around grand heists and pure chaos, GTA offers up a sharp critique of pop culture and society in general. While not related to baseball, there are themes that intermingle.
On November 18, the Kansas City Royals traded former All-Star Maikel Garcia and right-handed pitchers James McArthur and L.P. Langevin to the Seattle Mariners in exchange for starting pitchers Bryce Miller and Logan Evans and reliever Jose A. Ferrer. Naturally, fans of both teams have already called the blockbuster trade a fleecing. Which team was on the wrong end of the fleecing varies depending on who you talk to. But that discussion does lead to an interesting topic regarding the Royals as a whole.
In an attempt to celebrate the release of GTA VI, now is the perfect time to reflect on some of the biggest acts of thievery in the trade market throughout the history of the Royals. Just recently, we took a look back on the nightmare deals that sent David Cone packing not once, but twice. Those trades left the Royals with a whole lot of nothing in return and only continued the cycle of futility that lasted for decades.
This time around, we’re going to revisit the trades that only benefited the Royals. Deals that many experts and fans still consider to be highway robbery to this day. Trades that left the other teams holding the bag and put the Royals in a better position to win.
The Royals have occasionally been accused of player theft throughout their history
Royals receive 1B John Mayberry and INF David Grangaard from the Astros for RHP Jim York, LHP Lance Clemons
We’re going to start this one off with a bang. In the fall of 1971, the Royals were in the market for offensive upgrades. On the heels of an 85-76 season, good for a second-place finish in the AL West, the Royals knew they needed to do something to get over the hump. So when Houston Astros first baseman John Mayberry became available, the Royals leapt at the opportunity to acquire him. The move failed to move the needle for the team in the short term, but it wasn’t because of Mayberry.
The slugger accumulated 21.4 bWAR in his six seasons in Kansas City. He clubbed 143 home runs and drove in 552 runs for the Royals during his tenure with the team, which included two All-Star appearances. On the flip side, the Astros were left wondering why they ever made the trade in the first place. RHP Jim York was good for a combined -0.7 bWAR in four seasons with Houston. Lefty Lance Clemons did provide some value for the club. He was traded to the St. Louis Cardinals in a deal to acquire pitcher Jerry Reuss.
Royals receive RHP Jeff Montgomery from the Reds for OF Van Snider
After a disappointing 1987 rookie campaign with the Cincinnati Reds, young RHP Jeff Montgomery was shipped off to Kansas City in exchange for outfielder Van Snider before the start of the 1988 season. That move proved to be quite beneficial to Montgomery’s career trajectory, eventually becoming the greatest closer that the team has ever had. He was selected to three All-Star teams during his 12-year tenure with the Royals. Montgomery notched 304 career saves with the Royals, good for the 28th most in MLB history.
Montgomery was never the most dominant closer in the game or a pitcher who would rack up the strikeouts. That never prevented him from getting the job done and finishing games for the Royals throughout his successful career. And all it cost the team was Van Snider, an outfielder who would only appear in 19 career at-bats. He collected just seven hits in 35 at-bats in his two seasons with the Reds. After 1989, he never came close to sniffing the big leagues again.
Royals receive OF Amos Otis from the Mets for OF Joe Foy and RHP Bob Johnson
In December 1969, the New York Mets sent outfielder Amos Otis and RHP Bob Johnson to the Kansas City Royals in exchange for Joe Foy. At the time, the trade wasn’t too shocking. Otis struggled a bit in his limited playing time in his first two seasons with the Mets. However, he immediately became an All-Star in Kansas City, putting up a 4.1 bWAR season in 1970. Otis was undoubtedly the best offensive player for the Royals that season, and he continued his high level of play throughout most of his 14-year career with the club.
Otis accumulated 44.8 bWAR during his time in Kansas City, nearly reaching 2,000 career hits with the Royals. He is regularly included as one of the greatest players in franchise history. Unfortunately for the Mets, Foy never came close to matching Otis’ success. Foy spent just one season with the team, hitting six home runs and driving in 37 runs in 322 at-bats. He was then selected by the Washington Senators in the 1970 Rule 5 Draft after the season.
