FanSided

Why a big September is crucial for these 3 KC Royals

A trio of Kansas City players need to do well this month.

By Mike Gillespie |
/ Megan Briggs/GettyImages
1 of 3
Next

September will end at Kauffman Stadium for the KC Royals, who then close out this distressing season October 1 with an afternoon game against the Yankees. There will be no trip to the postseason, no victory parade, no celebration.

That doesn't mean, though, that the campaign's final full month isn't important. The Royals still have a sliver-slim chance of avoiding the worst record in franchise history (after losing to Boston Sunday, they must go 15-9 the rest of the way to finish with fewer losses than the 2005 club's record 106), and some nice personal marks are within reach for Salvador Perez, Bobby Witt Jr. and Brady Singer.

But those stars aren't the only players for whom September is critical. Their performances down the stretch could help shape the Kansas City future of several other Royals.

Consider these three among them.

A KC Royals pitcher needs some excellent September appearances

Jackson Kowar seemed to have the baseball world firmly by its tail when Kansas City called him up to the majors in 2021. He'd been a successful minor league pitcher to that point, and wildly so that season at Triple-A Omaha, where he was 5-0 with an 0.85 ERA when the Royals promoted him in early June.

Sadly, success didn't follow Kowar to Kansas City. His first three appearances went so badly — opponents battered him for 10 runs and 11 hits in five innings — that manager Mike Matheny didn't call on him again before the club dispatched him back to Omaha. Kowar wasn't much better when he returned in September, and he finished the season 0-4 with a 9.95 ERA.

The road between Omaha and Kansas City has been well-traveled by Kowar ever since. He's yet to recapture the pitching magic he first rode to the big leagues; in fact, that he's given up 35 runs in 36 innings over the 2022 and 2023 major league seasons explains why he rarely pitches in high-leverage situations.

Kowar didn't have a decision last year, and doesn't have one this season. He's never saved a game, or had the opportunity to do so, for the Royals. His two career holds don't count for much. And he's given up 18 runs (14 earned) and walked 15 in 20.1 innings this year.

All that clouds Kowar's Kansas City future. If he doesn't pitch better down the stretch, what we said about him before this season began may prove true — 2023 could end up being his last Royal shot.

Who's next?

A solid September should solidify Michael Massey's status with the KC Royals

Like Jackson Kowar before him, an excellent minor league track record propelled Michael Massey to the majors. And like Kowar, Massey hasn't enjoyed the kind of success in the big leagues that he did in the minors.

But their cases are different. Kowar's struggles keep him bouncing back and forth between Kansas City and Omaha, while save for the few games he played during a short return to Omaha and a subsequent injury rehab assignment, Massey hasn't seen a minor league pitch since the Royals called him up last summer.

But Massey's stay in The Show hasn't been flawless. Consistently cool is the hot bat he maintained in the minors — he's slashing .224/.267/.356 after going 0-for-2 against Boston Sunday, and .230/.281/.363in 161 games since breaking in last year.

Unless they improve, those numbers, and a decent glove (he's made only six errors in 593 second base chances) may not be enough to provide the kind of job security Massey undoubtedly covets. And although he seems better suited to be a Whit Merrifield-type super-utility player, newcomer Nick Loftin, Kansas City's fifth-best prospect per MLB Pipeline, could give Massey a run for his money at second.

Massey, then, bears watching this month. Only in May did he hit well (.319) before batting .118 in June, .215 in July, and .228 in August. Improving significantly at the plate as the season winds down would behoove him.

Moving on...

A rookie pitcher needs to be much better for the KC Royals this month

The case rookie Royals reliever James McArthur is making for a spot in next season's Kansas City bullpen isn't strong.

In fact, it's pretty weak, and one McArthur, who came to the organization in the early season trade with the Cubs that sent minor league outfielder Junior Marin to Chicago, needs to strengthen considerably if he wants to see Kauffman Stadium in 2024.

His numbers tell the tale. McArthur, who reported to Triple-A Omaha immediately after the trade and has been called up to Kansas City four times, has given up 12 runs in 9.2 innings spread over eight appearances for the Royals, and opponents are hitting him at a dangerous .375 clip. And the dark memory of his June 28 big league debut, a one-inning stint against Cleveland during which he faced 10 Guardians and gave up seven runs on six hits, is unfortunately still fresh.

Disregarding that game as a possible outlier doesn't much change the McArthur equation — even though he held the Red Sox scoreless in the 1.2 innings he faced them Sunday, he's still burdened by an ugly 11.17 ERA.

And giving this season's opponents too many runs isn't a flaw limited to his time in Kansas City. He yielded 13 runs in 16 innings for the Cubs' Triple-A affiliate before Chicago shipped him off to the Royals,

Encouraging and commendable, however, is McArthur's 3.98 ERA at Omaha. But that's against minor league hitters; assuming he stays on KC's active roster the rest of the season, he risks beginning next season back in Omaha if his big league numbers don't get better.

More KC Royals News

manual

Next
Home / KC Royals News

Schedule