Saturday roster moves raise 3 big questions for KC Royals

With just three weeks left on their 2023 schedule, the KC Royals announced four significant changes to their roster before Saturday's game with Toronto. To the Injured Lists go pitcher Austin Cox (60-day List with a left knee issue manager Matt Quatraro reportedly says could be an ACL injury) and catcher Freddy Fermin (10-day with a finger fracture), while Brad Keller returns from a long IL stint and catcher Tyler Cropley heads from Double-A to the majors.

The moves, all but Keller's reactivation prompted by necessity, beg some questions.

Will missing the rest of the season hurt KC Royals reliever Austin Cox?

Until suffering his knee injury Friday night against Toronto, Cox, part of the club's 2018 draft class that boasted a slew of top pitching prospects, was making an arguably decent case to return to Kansas City's bullpen next season. He left the game with a 4.54 ERA and 33 strikeouts in 35.2 innings, numbers that, while not ideal, certainly aren't the worst among KC's lackluster relief corps.

But landing on the 60-day IL with three weeks left in this campaign means he won't pitch again until next year, and might impact whatever plans the Royals have for him. He's eligible for this winter's Rule 5 draft, which means Kansas City must include him on its 40-man roster in November or risk losing him to another club in the December draft. The Royals left him unprotected last year; a knee injury won't improve his prospects for 2023 Rule 5 protection, and could give other clubs pause should Kansas City not shield him this time around.

Next question...

What does Tyler Cropley's promotion to the KC Royals mean for Logan Porter?

Nothing good. Bumping Cropley up from Double-A when he's never spent a moment in Triple-A all but ends Porter's chances, of making his big league debut this season.

Or with the Royals at any time.

Kansas City choosing Cropley over Porter to back up Salvador Perez is at least somewhat surprising. Cropley, signed by the club after the Washington system let him go during the 2020 season, played just 26 games in 2021 and 36 last season, and was hitting .234 in 43 games at Northwest Arkansas when the Royals called him up Saturday. He owns a paltry .210 career minor league average.

Porter, on the other hand, is batting only .235 at Omaha, a number arising primarily from a prolonged slump, but has 13 homers and a nice .342 OBP in 109 games. He also slashed .301/.442/.476 and homered 13 times across a 2022 season split between Double-A and Triple-A.

That Porter's bat is better than Cropley's renders the decision to bring Cropley to Kansas City curious. Promoting Porter would have made more sense — the Royals could have finally taken a look at him at and behind the plate.

But this isn't the first time the Royals have passed on Porter when they could have promoted him; failing to give him a chance now, with only three weeks left to play and the club going nowhere, could have been a low-risk but valuable opportunity.

And probably signals a lack of any future for Porter with the Royals.

More about the KC Royals