Grading KC Royals aggressive moves on trade deadline day

2 of 3

The MLB trade deadline has come and gone, refocusing baseball on the on-field product as the postseason approaches. The KC Royals were buyers at the trade deadline for the first time in nearly a decade, investing further into a surprising 2024 season.

Royals general manager J.J. Picollo and company gave the Royals some much-needed reinforcements, focusing much of the resources on pitching. The Hunter Harvey trade, while costly, has yet to bear its fruit. The Michal Lorenzen acquisition was a quick-developing shock and the veteran's final role is yet to be determined.

The KC Royals trade deadline was unlike recent years in all the best ways.

Tuesday, July 30, would decide the trade deadline's tone. Would the Royals be passive and rely on their in-house options down the stretch? Or would more trades bolster this team, a Wild Card contender in a volatile American League?

Royals fans had their answer by 5 p.m. Central Daylight Time.

The Royals ended Tuesday by acquiring right-handed pitcher Lucas Erceg, and then versatile infielder Paul DeJong. While the roster ripple effects of those two moves have yet to settle, the dugout ultimately had positive feelings toward the trade deadline's result.

"We feel like we upgraded the team and that's really important," manager Matt Quatraro said ahead of Tuesday's tilt against the Chicago White Sox. "I think Erceg is a really exciting arm. I think he is someone who will help us in leverage...first thing [DeJong] said is whatever I have to do to help this team win, ao another guy that fits."

One new arm. One new bat. How will they affect the Royals? Did Kansas City overpay for optics or make the calculated moves they needed? Let's dive in.

KC Royals acquire the sought-after strikeout stuff

KC Royals receive: RHP Lucas Erceg

Oakland Athletics receive: RHP Mason Barnett, RHP Will Klein, OF Jared Dickey

If you saw my relievers article from Monday morning, you know that I am a Lucas Erceg fan. Yet, I thought the powerful righty would be out of Kansas City's budget, especially in a trade market where relievers fetched such high returns. Boy, was it a welcome surprise to hear Kansas City didn't balk at the asking price and acquired Erceg.

A former position player, Erceg's MLB career is still relatively young. But he has been nothing but stellar for Oakland, serving as All-Star reliever Mason Miller's setup man for much of 2024. If it weren't for Miller's electric performances, more eyes would rightfully be on Erceg and what he brings to a bullpen.

Quatraro himself said that Erceg is the high-leverage arm that Kansas City desperately needs, especially after another rough stretch from reliever James McArthur. His fastball lives near triple digits, averaging 98.4 MPH this year. Erceg has always had that fastball, but the improved command of it makes that pitch and his slider play up even more. The righty has only three saves this year with Oakland, but he is expected to improve on that mark with a bigger role in Kansas City.

Kansas City gave up a significant amount for Erceg due to his potential and long-term team control well into the next decade. Barnett, a top-five prospect in the Royals system as ranked by MLB Pipeline, had been on fire since late June, increasing his trade value. Klein, a former Futures Game representative, was on the Royals' 26-man roster and was expected to get opportunities in the struggling bullpen. Lastly, Dickey joined Kansas City after the 2023 MLB Draft and quickly advanced to High-A Quad Cities.

It may be an old adage, but I first heard Royals Farm Report's Alex Duvall say, "Trade your relievers early and often." Bullpen arms are some of the most volatile trade pieces a team can acquire. That position's track record does cause me some concern, but Erceg hasn't had those massive peaks and valleys yet in his young MLB career. The Royals got a player that is only trending up from Tuesday.

Grade: A

Questions arise among KC Royals fans after Paul DeJong addition

KC Royals receive: INF Paul DeJong

Chicago White Sox receive: RHP Jarold Rosado

You could have given me 100 guesses as to which batter the Royals would acquire at the trade deadline, and Paul DeJong would not have crossed my mind. The 30-year-old infielder has bounced around MLB in recent years after making a name for himself with the St. Louis Cardinals but experienced a minor renaissance with the Chicago White Sox. That was enough for Kansas City to take a shot on him.

DeJong is a shortstop by nature but has played at other positions in his MLB career. With multiple appearances at third and second base, that was enough for the Royals to presumably upgrade from an Adam Frazier or Nick Loftin. DeJong also has serious pop in his bat, smacking 18 home runs in 102 games this year. He already has the third-most homers among all Royals batters without making a single plate appearance for the team.

The veteran is a rental player, so this isn't a long-term commitment from either side. He slots nicely into a bench role, giving Quatraro another pinch-hitting option against righties, whom DeJong is significantly better against. Plus, he brings recent postseason experience to the Kansas City clubhouse. He has 14 postseason appearances in his MLB career, coming as recently as the 2022 Wild Card round.

Rosado is a lottery ticket, albeit a productive one. the 22-year-old righty has 27 relief appearances made with the Low-A Columbia Fireflies this year. He posted a 1.85 ERA in those games, with a 1.05 WHIP and 45 strikeouts across 39 innings pitched.

I fail to grasp the logic behind this trade, but I believe it only slightly enhances the Royals bench. This is essentially a rental trade for a player who is years away from the majors. What's the worst-case scenario here?

Grade: C+

More from Kings of Kauffman

feed

Home / KC Royals News