Can the KC Royals find pitching help on Chicago's North Side?

/ Mark J. Rebilas-USA TODAY Sports
2 of 3
Next

Almost two full months have passed since this winter's free agent and trade markets opened and, not unpredictably, the KC Royals haven't done anything anyone can say is transformative.

Yes, the club has signed major league free agent pitchers Ryan Yarbrough, Jordan Lyles, Mike Mayers and Nic Wittgren, but alone or together, those transactions aren't likely to greatly improve one of the worst pitching staffs in the big leagues. And the minor leaguers are bets on the future, not the present.

So perhaps the news that general manager J.J. Picollo may have designs on adding more new pitching to the Royal mix should come as no surprise. The Kansas City Star's Lynn Worthy reports Picollo as saying this about that:

I think we have to still explore (adding to the rotation)," Picollo said. "Because we just don't know how it's going to end up throughout the offseason, regardless of who the pitcher is. So if there's an opportunity for us to get deeper and get better, we can't close the door right now.

The cream of the free agent pitching crop is already spoken for, so who Picollo might target remains to be seen. Could three hurlers late of the Chicago Cubs be possibilities?

A former member of the KC Royals is one of three available Cub free agents.

Alec Mills started his professional career with Kansas City after the club chose him in the 22nd round of the 2012 amateur draft. His major league debut in 2016 was brief and unimpressive: he pitched once in May and twice in September out of the KC bullpen and gave up five runs in 3.1 innings. The Royals traded him to the Cubs that winter.

Mills, 31 and a righthander, threw a 2020 no-hitter against Milwaukee; other than that gem, however, his Chicago years have been mundane. He's 12-14 with a 4.84 ERA as a Cub and, due in no small part to missing most of the campaign with lower back and right quad injuries, was 0-1, 9.68 last season.

Mills' pedestrian record and recent injury history makes him a pitcher the Royals don't need to pursue. But what about Chicago's other two free agent hurlers?

A lefthanded starting pitcher might offer some help to the KC Royals.

Drew Smyly was the best of the four Chicago free agent pitchers when the offseason began, but the Cubs deprived other suitors of him by signing him to a new two-year deal late last month. Smyly's return made Wade Miley probably the top prize among the remaining three.

Miley, 36, is a 12-year major league veteran with a 99-94, 4.13 ERA career record who's pitched for Arizona, Cincinnati, Baltimore, Boston, Chicago, Seattle, Houston and Milwaukee. He spent more time with the Diamondbacks than anyone else, going 38-35 from 2011-2014, including an All-Star 16-11 season.

Miley also went 14-6 for the Astros in 2019 and 12-7 for the Reds in 2027.

Like Alec Mills, injuries plagued Miley last season: he spent much of the year on the Injured List with left elbow inflammation and a left shoulder strain, and posted a 2-2, 3.16 record in nine big league appearances, including eight starts. He also went 0-0, 4.50 and struck out 15 in 22 minor league rehabilitation assignments innings.

The Royals could certainly make worse choices than Miley for their 2023 starting rotation. But at 36 and coming off an injury-riddled 2022 season, he wouldn't be their best.

Steven Brault is a veteran who could start or relieve for the KC Royals.

With 52 starts and 64 relief appearances to his major league credit, Steven Brault might be a swingman candidate for Kansas City.

There are reasons, though, that the Royals should think twice before giving Brault's agent a call.

Brault hasn't distinguished himself as a starter or a reliever. He's 6-15 with a 4.58 ERA in the former role and 6-3, 5.04 in the latter; neither ERA is commendable, and the 5.04 mark in relief is simply too high for a good big league bullpen piece.

The lefthander has also battled control throughout his seven-season big league career. Only twice has he recorded BB/9s under 4.00, and he's equaled or exceeded 5.00 twice (5.60 in 2018 and 5.00 last year).

And, like fellow Cub free agents Alec Mills and Wade Miley, injuries befell Miley in 2022. He was able to pitch just nine times for Chicago and eight times in the minors. He finished 0-0, 3.00 for the Cubs and 2-0, 10.29 (eight runs surrendered in seven innings) on minor league rehab assignments.

Should Kansas City make a run at Brault? Probably not. He doesn't represent a good long-term investment for the franchise and the Royals already have better, younger starters and relievers who need the work Brault would get if signed.

dark. Next. Don't write off Ryan O'Hearn just yet

There isn't a lot for Kansas City to choose from among the Cubs' free agent pitchers.

Next