It's time for the KC Royals to address the Vinnie Pasquantino question

Seven long seasons, most of them mediocre, have passed since Eric Hosmer played his last game as a Kansas City Royal. A darling of Royals fans almost from the moment he broke into the majors in 2011, the club wanted Hosmer back when his contract expired after the 2017 campaign, but he headed for San Diego and the $143 million long-term contract the Padres gave him.

Hosmer left the Royals with gaping holes at first base and the plate, and only now with Vinnie Pasquantino should the team feel it's filled both gaps. Although the big slugger hasn't hit or fielded quite as well as Hosmer did, he's proving to be much more than merely serviceable.

And unless the Royals do the presently unthinkable thing and trade him, Pasquantino figures to be in Kansas City a long time, especially because he's under so much team control — only after next season will he be eligible for arbitration, and he can't test free agency until the 2028 campaign ends.

But with teams increasingly willing to lock up young stars with early contract extensions, Pasquantino has to be on the Royals' list of extension candidates. Now the question is whether the time is right for a new deal.

Why it might be time for the KC Royals to extend Vinnie Pasquantino

Three threshold criteria — production, popularity, and potential — should drive any extension decision, including the one KC general manager J.J. Picollo and principal owner John Sherman will eventually make about Pasquantino.

Production heads the list — Picollo and Sherman must decide whether Pasquantino has given the club enough to warrant long-term consideration. Except for those times injuries have forced him out of the lineup (more on that shortly), he's delivered. In 2022, he slashed .295/.383/.450 with 10 homers in 72 games after the Royals brought him up in June to replace Carlos Santana; in 2023, he managed nine homers and 26 RBI before right labrum surgery ruined his season in June; and this year, he had 97 RBI, 19 homers, and 30 doubles when the fractured thumb he suffered in August put him on the Injured List for the rest of the regular season.

Overall, Pasquantino has homered 38 times, driven in 149 runs, and slashed .267/.335/.445 in 264 games. His defense isn't as good as four-time Gold Glover Hosmer's, but he's not a defensive liability.

How about popularity?

Does Vinnie Pasquantino's potential justify an early extension?

Talent-wise, Pasquantino has the potential to be good for several more seasons. He's only 27 and will unquestionably improve as he refines his already adequate skills at the major-league level.

However, his health — the reason he's missed so much playing time during his short big league career — isn't free from concern.

First came the right shoulder injury he suffered during his rookie season. It surfaced just a few days short of the two-month anniversary of his major league debut and kept him out of the lineup for almost three weeks.

Last year was worse. Pasquantino's shoulder flared up again in June, he wisely underwent surgical repair, and the slugger didn't see game action again until this year's spring training.

But freeing himself from shoulder problems didn't kill Pasquantino's injury bug — the fractured thumb he suffered in late August wrecked the rest of his 2024 regular season. He returned for the playoffs but went only 3-for-23.

Should his injury history squelch any extension discussions, at least for now? Probably not. It appears surgery may have solved Pasquantino's shoulder woes, and his broken thumb arose from a freakish play at first base that seems unlikely to reoccur.

So, Picollo and Sherman should seriously consider sitting down with with Pasquantino this winter. Maybe they can work something out; maybe they can't. But it's worth a try.

More about the KC Royals from Kings of Kauffman