The Kansas City Royals have had some very good players throughout their history, yet George Brett remains the only Hall of Famer wearing the KC on his cap in Cooperstown. If you look at the list of recent players to suit up for the Royals, only a select few seem to have a chance to eventually join Brett one day. This includes Bobby Witt Jr., and even he has a long way to go.
On November 16, the 2027 Baseball Writers' Association of America Hall of Fame ballot was officially released. It included 13 players returning from last year’s ballot and 14 newcomers. Of those newcomers, three players had suited up for the Royals for at least one season in their careers. This includes starting pitcher Ervin Santana and relievers Wade Davis and Joakim Soria.
Let’s just get this out of the way. None of these former Royals pitchers will be enshrined in Cooperstown next year. That doesn’t mean that their careers are not worth remembering. In fact, to even get to this point is an accomplishment in itself. In general, for a player to be eligible for the Hall of Fame, they must play at least 10 seasons in the big leagues. While there are occasional exceptions, a ballplayer’s longevity is something that Hall of Fame voters take very seriously.
Just think about it. Even some of the worst players in MLB history were still among the best baseball players around. To reach the majors, a player needs to display a consistently high level of talent to rise above the rest. Santana, Davis, and Soria each proved that they were not only worthy of making it to the big leagues, but also of sticking around for more than a decade. Although they may not be bound for the Hall of Fame, each pitcher had their moments.
These former Royals pitchers did more than enough to earn their place in the Hall of Pretty Dang Good
Wade Davis
As a starting pitcher for the Tampa Bay Rays, Wade Davis was about as mediocre a player as there was in the league. By no means was he a bad pitcher, but he failed to really take his game to the next level in 88 career starts for the Rays. With a career 4.57 ERA and 6.3 strikeouts per nine rate as a starter, Davis had a fairly low ceiling in the rotation. If he stayed there, he may never have even played longer than just a handful of seasons.
As a reliever, Davis saw his ERA shrink to 3.25, and his strikeouts per nine rate explode all the way to 10.7 in 469 career appearances. Tampa Bay first experimented with Davis in the bullpen during the 2012 season, and it worked wonderfully. However, after being dealt to the Royals that offseason, Davis moved back to the rotation where he struggled immensely in 2013. The team moved him to the bullpen once again, and Davis never looked back. He was voted to the All-Star game three years in a row from 2015 to 2017 and became one of the game’s best closers.
Despite having one heck of a peak as a reliever, Davis was not an elite pitcher long enough to be worthy of any serious consideration for the Hall of Fame. He will likely not receive the required 5% of votes to remain on the ballot next year. But what a run he had.
Joakim Soria
Unlike Davis, the Royals never really viewed Joakim Soria as a starting pitcher when they selected him from the San Diego Padres during the 2006 Rule 5 draft. In hindsight, that move is probably what allowed Soria to enjoy such a long and successful career. Right out of the gate, it was clear that Soria had a special talent. With a 2.48 ERA and 0.942 WHIP in 62 games during his debut season in 2007, Soria finished 7th in voting for AL Rookie of the Year.
From there, Soria appeared to only be getting stronger for the Royals. In his first four seasons in Kansas City, he racked up 132 saves and became a two-time All-Star. However, by 2011, Soria ran into his fair share of struggles in the closer’s role. While he notched another 28 saves, he was no longer the shutdown reliever that he once was. After undergoing Tommy John surgery in April 2012, Soria occasionally flirted with returning to his dominant form throughout his career. He just couldn’t do it consistently, though.
With 229 career saves during his 14-year career, Soria has the 45th most in MLB history. Not too shabby at all. He’s also the type of closer the Royals wish they still had on the roster. Unfortunately, his best years likely won’t be enough to help him be enshrined in Cooperstown. It’s doubtful that Soria will get the required 5% of votes to stay on the ballot, but with a weak class, he could potentially find his way through for another year.
Ervin Santana
By no means was Ervin Santana ever considered to be one of the top pitchers in baseball. That doesn’t mean that he didn’t enjoy successful stretches during his 16-year career in the big leagues. With a career 4.11 ERA in 425 starts, Santana was one of those sneaky-good pitchers who saw himself occasionally enter the Cy Young Award conversation a few times during his playing days.
When he was on, Santana could be as lights-out as any pitcher in baseball. He tossed 11 shutouts in his career, including a no-hitter against Cleveland in 2011. After pitching for the Los Angeles Angels for the first eight years of his career, Santana was traded to the Royals in October 2012. Although he wasn’t quite as dominant in his lone season in Kansas City, Santana had a 3.24 ERA and a 1.142 WHIP in 211 innings of work in 2013.
With 27.0 career bWAR, Santana was a fairly valuable pitcher during his 16 years in the big leagues. But even with his incredibly high peaks, Santana was never able to pitch at that high level long enough to warrant extensive Hall of Fame consideration. Like Soria, he might be able to luck into hitting that 5% threshold, but it’s not likely.
