Kansas City Royals: The Teams Potential Right Field Options

SURPRISE, AZ - MARCH 02: Manager Ned Yost
SURPRISE, AZ - MARCH 02: Manager Ned Yost
1 of 5
Next

When Spring Training started, it seemed that the only outfield position that was needing to be identified was center field. With the signing of Jon Jay, the outfield seemed set. Until recently. 

Saturday night brought some unwanted news to the Kansas City Royals. Assumed right fielder, Jorge Bonifacio failed a PED test resulting in an 80-game suspension. The original outfield of Alex Gordon, Jon Jay, and Bonifacio is no longer a thing to start the season.

Therefore, the Royals seemingly open up auditions again to fill the open position. Many players have impressed during Spring Training, which has not helped answer the question of who gets the spot.

We are going to take a look at possible options. Some that might be most likely to happen, could happen, and the one wild card option.

“Most Likely” Outfield Options

Jorge Soler

Starting with some of the more basic options, Jorge Soler immediate jumps to the top of the list. After being traded for in 2016, Soler was thought to be the Royals right fielder going into the 2017 season.

Unfortunately, Soler struggled during his chance in 2016 season. He was called up in May and slashed a .164/.292/.273 average over 18 games. After adding more games to his total, the numbers actually got worse. Over the full 35 games he played, he slashed a horrible .144/.245/.258 average and just seven extra-base hits, two being homeruns.
Unfortunately, Soler struggled during his chance in 2016 season. He was called up in May and slashed a .164/.292/.273 average over 18 games. After adding more games to his total, the numbers actually got worse. Over the full 35 games he played, he slashed a horrible .144/.245/.258 average and just seven extra-base hits, two being homeruns. /

He also had just six runs-batted-in, and his wRC+ was a dreadful 32. Again, for perspective, the average offensive player scores 100 on the wRC+ scale. Knowing that makes that number even harder to look at. Due to his struggles, Bonifacio was accelerated and eventually won the right field position.

On the positive side, while Soler was in Omaha he did show his upside. Over 74 games, Soler slashed a solid .267/.388/.564 and had 33 extra-base hits, 24 being homeruns. His 145 wRC+ is also something to be excited about.

So far during Spring Training, he has a less than impressive .211 batting average. However, he does have four homeruns.

Whether they decide to put Soler in right field or keep him as the designated hitter, the Royals need the type of performances he had in Omaha to translate to the big leagues. Due to the fact that he was traded for to potentially be the team’s right fielder, I would not be surprised if he gets the early nod when Spring Training breaks.

Paulo Orlando

We all know Paulo Orlando. In 2015 he was seemingly promoted to the fourth outfield spot over Jarrod Dyson, typically coming in as a defensive replacement for Alex Rios. Then in 2016, after playing in 128 games, Orlando posted a surprising .302/.329/.405 slash. Therefore, going into 2017 fans had hopes of what he could do.

Unfortunately, Orlando seemed lost at the plate. Over 39 games, Orlando posted a very disappointing .198/.255/.302 slash. This resulted in him being demoted to Omaha where the unlucky streak continued. After fouling a ball off his leg, Orlando ended up fracturing his shin.

This did limit his playing time in Omaha, but overall he looked promising again. He ended up hitting .306/.375/.414 over 42 games. He has also continued those numbers into Spring Training, hitting .458 so far.

Orlando could be the starting right fielder in 2018, but the drastic difference between 2016 and 2017 may raise a lot of question marks. Who is the real Paulo Orlando?

“Could Be” Outfield Options

Michael Saunders

The Royals added Michael Saunders at the beginning of Spring Training after being released from the Pittsburgh Pirates when they traded for Corey Dickerson. He was a long shot at finding a spot on the Royals 25-man roster, but due to recent events, he might have increased his odds of making the big league roster.

Saunders has actually had a nice Spring Training. He has hit .308 over his eight games and has shown that he can play both left field and right field. That type of versatility can help open up the outfield some.

When the Royals signed Saunders, they seem to have been hoping that he could re-create his 2016 All-Star season or provide a competent outfielder who could hold a spot down until the “next guy” was ready.
When the Royals signed Saunders, they seem to have been hoping that he could re-create his 2016 All-Star season or provide a competent outfielder who could hold a spot down until the “next guy” was ready. /

Originally, I thought signing Saunders could have been for playing center field. However, with the signing of Jay that obviously is not the case. But his ability to play all three outfield positions is enticing. If Saunders continues to impress during Spring Training, I would not be surprised if he is the starting right fielder for the Royals.

The only catch is finding a spot on the 40-man roster for Saunders if he does end up “making” the team.

Tyler Collins

I must admit, I did not think Tyler Collins had much of a chance at being a starter or anything more than just depth for the Royals. I figured that the team had enough depth, that Collins would find himself being pushed into the background.

However, over 15 games he has done everything to not be pushed backward. He has hit .313 and showed that he is a solid defensive outfielder.

I know that Spring Training does not tell the whole story. When you look at his regular season numbers they show that he is far from a .300 hitter. For his career, he has a slash of .235/.299/.380 and last year had a .193/.278/.333 slash over 49 games in Detroit.

Same story as Soler though. In the minors last year he showed his upside. Over 74 games he posted a much more appealing .288/358/.462 slash.

The identity of Collins is still unknown. Based off of how things ended in Detroit, it seems like the environment he was in was not going to work well for him. Maybe being in an environment like the Royals clubhouse will do him some good, and help boost his productivity level.

“Wild Card” Outfield Option

Whit Merrifield

Here we go again, right? Ned Yost made a comment about how he could move Whit Merrifield all around because of his ability to be a “super” utility player. Throughout Spring Training he has played many different positions. So what would it take to make him the candidate for right field?

It is quite simple. It seems like Yost really wants Adalberto Mondesi to be with the big league club. After Dayton Moore signed Alcides Escobar back to the club, that

SCOTTSDALE, AZ – FEBRUARY 26: Whit Merrifield
SCOTTSDALE, AZ – FEBRUARY 26: Whit Merrifield /

basically eliminated all chances of Mondesi playing shortstop, leaving Merrifield at second base being moved. Therefore, having the right field open now give the Royals some flexibility when it comes to moving Merrifield.

Merrifield could assume his spot in right field, allowing Modesi to take second base. By doing this, they can see what Mondesi has in store for the year. If Mondesi struggles, moving Merrifield back to second base is going to be easy.

Merrifield has played in the outfield. He has played 14 big league games in right field, as well as 71 minor league games in right field. He actually has experience at every position besides catcher. Before you ask, he has logged 1.0 innings as a pitcher at Northwest Arkansas in 2013. The guy does it all! [almost]

Final Thoughts

If I had to guess right now, I would say that Saunders gets the nod at right field. I feel like Soler is going to be the teams designated hitter (I do not believe Yost when he says the DH position will be a rotated position. He has said that for years and it has yet to happen) and Orlando seems like the perfect fourth outfielder. Collins could be a guy they stash in Omaha to see if he can consistently hit.

It is a very real possibility that Merrifield is the right fielder come Opening Day. I just believe they will wait to start Mondesi’s service time when the rest of the young core is ready, or close to ready, to make the jump.

So what do you think Royals fans? Do you have an idea of who will be the right fielder during Bonifacio’s suspension? Let us know below!

Next