Jul 10, 2014; Kansas City, MO, USA; Kansas City Royals right fielder Raul Ibanez (18) makes a fielding error against the Detroit Tigers in the fifth inning at Kauffman Stadium. Mandatory Credit: John Rieger-USA TODAY Sports

The Raul Ibanez Experiment Needs to End


It was a good story at the beginning. Raul Ibanez was back where he got his first chance to be an everyday player, possibly helping the Royals get to the playoffs. He started out well, going 3-8 with a home run and scoring two runs in his first two appearances back in Kansas City. It seemed as though the reunion had a chance to work out as Dayton Moore and the Royals had hoped.

However, reality set in quickly. After his quick start, Ibanez has not done anything at all at the plate, going 0-23 since his eighth inning home run on July 2nd. His bat has looked slow, as he has routinely been behind even decent fastballs. It is at the point where Ibanez appears to be cheating for the fastball, with his swing in the awkward position of being too fast for offspeed pitches and behind the heater.

Things have not been much better for Raul Ibanez in the field. While he has displayed a knack of positioning himself in the perfect spot for almost every player, Ibanez has the range of a statue. Actually, that comparison is unfair….to the statue. At least it is understandable why an inanimate object would not have any range.

Instead of playing Jarrod Dyson and Lorenzo Cain, two of the more productive players for the Royals this season, the Royals have continued to trot Ibanez out, playing either left or right virtually every day since being signed. Even though Alex Gordon is out until after the All-Star Break, at the minimum, Ibanez still does not serve a purpose in the Royals outfield. At least Justin Maxwell had more range than a step and a half and can hit above his body weight.

At this point, one has to wonder when The Great Raul Ibanez Experiment is going to end. It was worthwhile to see if he had any life left in his bat, giving the Royals the power bat they need at minimal cost. However, the hope that Ibanez can, in fact, still be a viable part of a major league roster has ended. He simply does not have anything left at this point.

Raul Ibanez has had a very good career. Unfortunately, his career appears to be over. It is time for the Royals to end the Ibanez Experiment.

Next Royals Game View full schedule »
Wednesday, Aug 2020 Aug6:40at Colorado RockiesBuy Tickets

Tags: Kansas City Royals Raul Ibanez

  • jimfetterolf

    Probably ends when Gordon comes back. Maxwell just accepted his demotion and I think he has to stay down for ten days before being recalled.

    • Dave Hill

      Gio played 20 games in left for Omaha last year. Bring him up for a couple of days. Just anyone with a chance at being productive.

      • jimfetterolf

        I’ld prefer Paulo Orlando at .315 with wheels or Whit Merrifield, currently hitting .368 and playing left in Omaha.

        • cardsfanatik

          Neither one will get the chance because they might actually do something

        • Bear Brinkman

          Was looking at Omaha today and noticed Maxwell is no longer on the 40 man roster?

          • jimfetterolf

            Royals DFA’ed him, no claims, accepted assignment to Omaha, has three days to report. Don’t think he’s on the 40 now. Not showing bat this year, defense is slipping, which is why I’ld give Orlando or Merrifield a chance. They did that with Lough last year and he produced, so maybe another one can.

      • moretrouble

        I have a feeling you’re not kidding. So, I won’t insult you by making a comment, LOL.

        • Dave Hill

          Honestly, it’s a matter of having anyone with more range than a corpse and the potential to actually hit the ball. Bring back Jeff Francoeur for a week. Anything to end this train wreck.

  • moretrouble

    I guess the idea of the article is that there are a number of minor league players capable of playing better than Ibanez … I mean, what’s the problem … those minor league guys are hitting .300+ and look pretty good, right?

    Bloggers see those minor league stats and get all excited about seeing those kids do the same thing at Kauffman. Then, they turn around and question why guys like Hosmer — who had very nice stats in the minors — are unable to produce at the same level in the MLB.

    There seems to be something wrong with the logic here, LOL.

    • Dave Lowe

      Head back under the bridge, troll. Ibanez flat out sucks at the plate and in the field. It was a BAD move by Dayton Moore.

      It’s a case of, “well, since Dayton picked up this guy, I have to play him.” He should only be brought in the game as a pinch hitter to supply some left-handed power. That’s it.

      While Gordon is out, it would have been just fine to play Aoki, Cain, and Dyson in the OF.