Royals Rotten Decade (2008)


During the 2000s, no major league team lost more games than the Kansas City Royals.  It was a decade where the negatives far outweighed the positives.  This is the ninth installment of the 11 part Royals Rotten Decade series.  I will briefly examine each season in the last decade before wrapping up the decade in the 11th and final part.

Part 9, the 2008 Royals (75-87) 691 RS / 781 RA

Payroll:  $58.2 million (24th) / Attendance: 1,578,922

Draft:  1B-Eric Hosmer (1st), LHP-Mike Montgomery (1st), 2B-Johnny Giovatella (2nd), RHP-Tyler Sample (3rd), RHP-Tim Melville (4th), LHP-John Lamb (5th)

Top Prospect:  3B-Mike Moustakas

Major League Debuts:
SS-Mike Aviles (27)
1B-Kila Ka’aihue (24)
C-Matt Tupman (28)
RHP-Yasuhiko Yabuta (35)
RHP-Devon Lowery (25)
RHP-Carlos Rosa (23)

Above 110 OPS+ (Minimum 50 AB)
151 1B-Ryan Shealy (28):  0.301/.354/.603 in 73 AB
121 SS-Mike Aviles (27):  0.325/.354/.480 in 419 AB
118 LF-David DeJesus (28):  0.307/.366/.452 in 518 AB

Above 110 ERA+ (Minimum 49.0 IP)*
272  RHP-Joakim Soria (24):  1.60 ERA, 0.86 WHIP, 8.8 SO/9 in 67.1 IP
165  RHP-Ramon Ramirez (26):  2.64 ERA, 1.23 WHIP, 8.8 SO/9 in 71.2 IP
146  RHP-Leo Nunez (24):  2.98 ERA, 1.24 WHIP, 4.8 SO/9 in 48.1 IP
126  RHP-Zack Greinke (24):  3.47 ERA, 1.28 WHIP, 8.1 SO/9 in 202.1 IP
125  LHP-Ron Mahay (37):  3.48 ERA, 1.39 WHIP, 6.8 SO/9 in 64.2 IP

*Bumped the IP requirement down by 1 so I could include Leo Nunez.

Mike Sweeney’s $11 million per year salary came off the books at the end of the 2007 and accounted for much of the drop in the team’s payroll from $67.1 million in 2007 to $58.2 million in 2008.  Overall attendance dropped by just under 38,000 from the 2007 season.  The signings of Jose Guillen, Yasuhiko Yabuta, Ron Mahay, and Miguel Olivo clearly didn’t energize the fan base enough, and the loss of fan favorite Sweeney certainly didn’t help.  On December 14th, 2007 Dayton pulled off his second best trade* when he sent 2004 2nd round pick, RHP-Billy Buckner, to the Arizona Diamondbacks.  In return, the Royals received 24-year old switch hitting infielder Alberto Callaspo.  It looked like a questionable deal at the time thanks in large part to the off-the-field issues surrounding Bert, but his performance on the field in 2008 and 2009 have tipped the scales in Kansas City’s favor.

*For those of you who don’t know, Ambiorix Burgos for Brian Bannister is universally regarded as Dayton’s best trade.

Coming off a 2007 season which saw the team score 706 runs, the 2008 team dipped slightly and scored 691.  With Sweeney gone, David DeJesus did his best to step up and lead the team and in the process, turned in the best OPS+ season of his career.  In addition to DJ, Mike Aviles forced his way into the lineup and turned in the finest season by a SS in Royals history.  Alex Gordon cut his SO, increased his BB, and showed a nice improvement across the board over his rookie season.  His progression was reflected in his OPS+ which climbed from 90 in 2007 to 109 in 2008.  Mark Teahen, Billy Butler, Alberto Callaspo, Jose Guillen, Miguel Olivo, and Mark Grudzielanek each finished the year with an OPS+ in the 90s.  The team had enough of an offense that a middle of the order impact bat could have made a huge difference.  Jose Guillen was brought in to be that guy and he did hit 20 HR, but his line of 0.264/.300/.438 didn’t come close to making him the offensive force Dayton Moore was banking on.  In fact, Aviles, DeJesus, and Olivo all out-slugged Guillen on the year.  Seven Royals hit 10 or more home runs on the season including the following:  Guillen (20), Gordon (16), Teahen (15), Olivo (12), DeJesus (12), Butler (11), and Aviles (10).  Joey Gathright led the team with 21 steals but contributed little else.  DJ was the only other Royals player to steal more than 10 bases, and finished with 11.  Gordon led the team in runs with 72 while Guillen led the team in RBI with 97.

The pitching staff held serve in terms of runs scored allowing 781 after allowing 778 in 2007.  Zack Greinke made 32 starts and established himself as one of the best pitchers in the AL.  Gil Meche and Kyle Davies gave the Royals two more above average starters finishing with an ERA+ of 109 and 107 respectively.  The real bright spot for the future was in the bullpen.  Nunez, Ram-Ram, and Robinson Tejeda gave the team 3 relievers, all younger than 26, who pitched at a very high level.  Joakim Soria proved that his rookie campaign in 2007 was no fluke, and established himself as one of the truly elite closers in baseball.  23-year RHP-Carlos Rosa appeared in only 2 games but showed fans why he was such a highly regarded prospect in the process.  Thanks to the bullpen the 2008 Royals were above 0.500 in one run games with a record of 20-18.

Kansas City closed the season on a high note with a September record of 18-8.  In the final standings the Royals wound up 13.5 games behind the Chicago White Sox (89-74) who needed a one-game playoff to claim the division title from the Minnesota Twins.  In addition to a good September, the Royals also finished with an above 0.500 record in June when they went 16-11.  In terms of runs scored and runs allowed, the 2008 results were very similar to those in 2007.  The difference in the W-L record between the two seasons was due to the fact that in 2008, they won 3 more games than their Pythagorean Win-Loss suggested.  You may recall that the opposite was true in 2007 when they won 5 fewer games than their Pythagorean W-L.

Heading into the offseason it was clear that the Jose Guillen signing was a mistake, and that he was incapable of being the offensive leader and impact bat the team needed.  Despite Dayton’s swing and miss on Guillen, a legitimate major league roster continued to take shape.  The Royals looked to have 3 starters in place with Gil Meche, Zack Greinke, and Kyle Davies.  Luke Hochevar and Brian Bannister figured to improve in 2009 and were the logical candidates to round out the 2009 rotation.  The bullpen also looked to be nearly set with veteran LHP-Ron Mahay and a slew of young RHPs Nunez, Ramon Ramirez, Tejeda, Rosa, and Soria.  On offense Butler, Gordon, Callaspo, and Aviles looked like they were ready to join the steady presence of Teahen and DeJesus.  Kila Ka’aihue, coming off a monster season in the minors wasn’t overmatched in 21 late season at bats and appeared to provide the team an in-house 1B/DH option for 2009.

There appeared to be little need to really mess with the roster.  We all know that Dayton Moore couldn’t help himself, but that is a story for another day.

(Wally Fish is the lead blogger for Kings of Kauffman and FanSided’s MLB Director.  Subscribe to his RSS feed and add him on Twitter to follow him daily.)

Next Royals Game View full schedule »
Wednesday, Sep 33 Sep7:10Texas RangersBuy Tickets

Tags: AL Central Alberto Callaspo Alex Gordon Baseball Billy Butler Carlos Rosa David DeJesus Devon Lowery Joakim Soria Joey Gathright Jose Guillen Kansas City Royals KC Kila Kaaihue Kyle Davies Leo Nunez Mark Gruzielanek Mark Teahen Matt Tupman Miguel Olivo Mike Aviles MLB Ramon Ramirez Ron Mahay Royals Ryan Shealy Yasuhiko Yabuta Zack Greinke

  • Kevin W.

    None of Dayton Moores trades during the 08/09 offseason were real bad trades.

    Mike Jacobs hit 11 HRs in 30 games for the Mets in 2005, did solid the couple following years, then hit 32 in ’08, in a ballpark that compares to Kauffman. The Royals needed power as well. The lineup wasn’t looking very good defensively or with any sort of power.

    Leo Nunez was someone who we were trying out for a few years now, and never had much success. He had a solid season in 2008, and his trade value was high. The only other time he had 40 games was in in 2005, and his ERA was 7.55. He wasn’t any type of high prized reliever we couldn’t afford to deal.

    The Coco trade looked even better on paper. Speed and Defense? UNTHINKABLE in Kansas City. Butler? Has none. Callapso? Has none. Aviles? Didn’t have much of both. Gordon? Below avg on both. DeJesus? Solid defense, very slow. Teahan? Below avg. defense solid speed. Gullien? Below avg. on both.

    Coco just came from hitting 280/340 in 360 ABs with 20 SBs, in the AL East.
    Ramon Ramirez on the other hand was an even worst project just like Nunez, though younger. Didn’t do good with the Rockies, little if any success in the Minors. Had a very good year with the Royals. Didn’t have the money to sign a Jacobs power type player, nor a Coco Crisp type player. Both of those trades looked good at the time they happened, and most GMs who had the opportunity to would’ve done it. Not to mention, he went out and signed Juan Cruz to replace them, who was regarded much higher than Leo or Ramon.

    Dayton Moore hasn’t done any bad trades in his time as GM. A couple bad signings (Farnsworth and Gullien), though a lot of very good and cheap signings/extensions (Soria, Greinke, Podsednick)

  • Wally Fish

    “Dayton Moore hasn’t done any bad trades in his time as GM.”

    Really? You like the results of the JP Howell for Joey Gathright deal? I’m not taking a shot, just pointing out a fact of life, ALL GMs make bad trades at one point or another.

    I disagree that both the Jacobs and Crisp trades looked good at the time they were made.

    Jacobs and his HR total in 2008 completely masked (in Dayton’s eyes anyway) the fact that he was a liability in every other facet of the game. Further it was completely unrealistic to expect him to hit 30+ HR in 2009. Outside of the HR numbers he didn’t fit into the team’s plans in 2009 or beyond and his presence also blocked a chance a playing time of Kila. Nunez wasn’t a huge loss, but the $3+ million they paid Jacobs in 2009 and the lost season for Kila made it a bad acquisition regardless of what they gave up.

    The Crisp trade ignored his injury history and track record (he’s never matched the hype around him) plus cost the team a very promising and cheap arm in Ramon Ramirez.

    Your assessment also ignores that Jacobs and Crisp were both expected to be available on the open market if Dayton had been more patient. Jacobs was a prime non-tender candidate, and the Red Sox weren’t going to keep Crisp around at his salary since Ellsbury had already claimed CF for himself.

    You can find a way to justify any deal if you look hard enough, but the reality is that together the two deals led to the team overreacting and signing Farnsworth to a terrible contract. Both trades also went against Dayton’s stated objectives when he took over the team. Instead of focusing on acquiring young talent, he was trading it away for older, more expensive players with limited to no upside.

    All that said, you miss the entire point. The team didn’t have to make those deals to continue to improve in 2009.