Replacing a KC Royals Legend: Dan Quisenberry Edition
The Royals look for someone new to close the door.
The closer is one of the most vital positions in baseball. KC Royals legend Dan Quisenberry was never a closer in the modern sense, but the submarining reliever was one of the leading figures in the sport's transition from so-called firemen to closers. However, as "Quiz" neared the end of his career, Kansas City turned its attention to finding his successor. The process took a few years to come to fruition, but in the end, the Royals found a new team legend who eventually broke many of Quisenberry's franchise records.
Dan Quisenberry was one of the most accomplished pitchers in Royals history
Quisenberry was a long shot to ever make it to The Show. Had it not been for a rash of injuries to the Royals' pitching staff, he may never have earned a shot at the big leagues. And he didn't exactly wow anyone when he first arrived in 1979 — it wasn't until manager Jim Frey encouraged him to work with Pittsburgh reliever Kent Tekulve, and transition from a sidearm to submarine delivery, that his career took off. And boy, did it really take off.
The distinctive reliever made his mark for the 1980 American League champion Royals with a major league-leading 33 saves. Unfortunately, he struggled in the World Series, probably because Frey used him in every game of that season's six-contest Fall Classic. This bump in the road came at the worst possible time, but it was one of few Quisenberry faced for the next half-decade.
Quisenberry won five Rolaids Relief Man of the Year awards from 1980-85, with the strike-shortened 1981 season standing out as the lone exception. That's tied for the most all-time with the great Mariano Rivera. Quisenberry led the majors in saves again in 1983, setting the Royals' franchise record with 45, and also led the American League in saves in 1982 (35). 1984 (44), and 1985 (37).
Quisenberry also led the AL in appearances in three of those seasons, all while pitching multiple innings in most outings. In fact, Quiz regularly pitched around 130 innings per season, so he wasn't just coming in to sew up the ninth inning. He also finished near the top in AL Cy Young and MVP voting several times.
In 1985, Quisenberry and the Royals reached the top of the mountain by winning the World Series. He recorded the win in the Royals' controversial Game 6 comeback. His numbers began to drop dramatically the next season, however: he still pitched an average of 50 innings over the next two seasons and recorded a sub-3.00 ERA, but his save totals dropped to 12 in 1986 and eight in 1987.
The Royals didn't have to look Farr for to replace Quiz
After spending his first major league season in Cleveland, Steve Farr joined the Royals just in time to win a World Championship in 1985. He made 16 appearances during the Royals' run for the crown, including three spot starts, and recorded one save. More success would follow.
Farr recorded eight saves in 1986, and in 1987 matched Quisenberry in appearances. Ironically, it's hard to argue he pitched better than Quiz for a team that finished only two games behind the World Champion Twins — Quisenberry posted a 2.76 ERA and eight saves, while Farr had a 4.15 ERA and only a single save. But when Quisenberry struggled in the first half of the 1988 season, the Royals saw the writing on the wall.
Kansas City released Quisenberry just before the All-Star Game, and he was promptly snapped up by the team across the state, forcing Royals fans to witness the unsightly image of him in a St. Louis Cardinals uniform. For his part, Quisenberry bounced back with a solid 1989 season, but he was a far cry from his prime. He moved to San Francisco in 1990 but tore his rotator cuff after only a few appearances. He chose to retire and, sadly, died from brain cancer in 1998.
The Royals handed their important late-inning work when Quisnberry's pitching deteriorated, but he didn't keep it for long.
Kansas City makes the call to another legend
Farr didn't pitch poorly in his new role. In 1988, he appeared in 62 games and posted a 2.50 ERA with 20 saves. But he had company in the pen. The Royals traded to get Jeff Montgomery from Cincinnati before the '88 season; the Reds had held out hope for Montgomery as a starter, but Kansas City committed to him as a bullpen piece.
Montgomery got his feet wet in 1988, and the Royals made him Farr's setup man the following season. As the Royals won 92 games and chased the juggernaut A's in the AL West, Farr and Montgomery put up remarkably similar numbers: both recorded 18 saves and appeared in 60-plus games, but Montgomery was dominant with a 1.37 ERA and 0.989 WHIP, while Farr had a 4.12 ERA ERA and 1.532 WHIP.
The Royals were shrewd enough to see where the future lay. Montgomery was better, younger and, at least for the time being, cheaper. They let Farr walk in free agency, he signed with the Yankees, and had a productive three-year run with them, recording 30 saves in 1992. Farr retired after the infamous 1994 strike.
Montgomery, on the other hand, etched his name in Royals' history. He saved 33 games in 1991, the first of five times he reached or bettered that mark during his career. His best season was 1993, when he tied Quisenberry's then-single-season club save record with 45. That mark was broken by Greg Holland, who posted 47 saves in 2013, but Montgomery still holds the club's career saves record with 304. He's a Royals club Hall of Famer and currently part of their broadcast team.
Like Quisenberry, the end came too soon for Montgomery. He saved 36 games in 1998, but his peripheral numbers dropped dramatically, setting the stage for a rough final season in 1999. Montgomery posted a 6.84 ERA and 1.812 WHIP in his last go-around, but that should not diminish his accomplishments in any way. Once he was gone, the Royals would not see another dominant closer until Joakim Soria arrived in 2007.