KC Royals: 3 sad conclusions from the Yankees series

(Photo by Rich Schultz/Getty Images)
(Photo by Rich Schultz/Getty Images)
1 of 3
Next
(Photo by Thearon W. Henderson/Getty Images)
(Photo by Thearon W. Henderson/Getty Images) /

The KC Royals arrived in New York for their just-completed trio of games with the Yankees six games below .500 and 10 games behind first place Chicago in the American League Central. After Thursday’s 8-1 loss to the Yanks, which didn’t seem that close, little has changed, and none of it for the good.

The defeat gave New York the series win—they won the second game 6-5 after losing the first by the same score—and dropped Kansas City seven games under .500. The Royals fell another half-game behind the White Sox and are 10 games out of the Wild Card.

Unfortunately on display were all the shortcomings that transformed the Royals from a division leader in early May into a club trying desperately to stay out of the Central cellar. (Only two games separate KC from last place Minnesota). Timely hitting was scarce, the starting rotation remains in disarray, and at least one key player doesn’t produce.

What conclusions can be drawn from this three-game series in The Bronx?

The KC Royals continue to struggle at the plate in important situations.

Sadly, Kansas City remains a club rarely disposed to hit in the clutch. The 2-for-5 the Royals hit with runners in scoring position Wednesday night was, despite their loss, the best of the series. They were 3-for-11 in Monday’s win, then 0-for-9 Thursday. The nine runners they left on base in Game 3 equaled the number they stranded Wednesday and gave the Royals 24 for the series.

It’s a habit the Royals must break. If they don’t, this season will be long before it reaches August.

(Mandatory Credit: Andy Marlin-USA TODAY Sports)
(Mandatory Credit: Andy Marlin-USA TODAY Sports) /

The starting rotation just isn’t improving for the KC Royals this season.

That the Kansas City rotation isn’t stellar is no secret. After Thursday’s loss, Royals starters have the second highest American League ERA (5.12), and have surrendered the third most runs and sixth most hits in the AL. Their 1.48 WHIP and .273 BAA are both the second worst in the league.

Only Danny Duffy has been consistently good when he’s pitched, and Mike Minor’s recent starts have, combined with the month Duffy missed on the Injured List, elevated him to staff leader status at 6-4.

The rest of the rotation, though, isn’t good enough to support any serious run at even a Wild Card spot. Its shortcomings were evident again Thursday when KC’s chosen starter once again put the club in an early hole. Brad Keller, pitching more like the Keller of 2019 (7-14, 4.19) than the Keller who won the team’s Pitcher of the Year awards the seasons before and after that, gave up a solo home run to Aaron Judge, the second Yankee batter of the game, and singles to the next two hitters before getting the second out, then allowed a one-run single to Rougned Odor.

So it was that Odor, a .196 hitter coming into the game, provided New York with all the runs it would require before the first inning was even over.

Judge tagged Keller for a run on a single in the second, and Luke Voit homered off him in the third. In his five innings, Keller surrendered nine hits, four runs, two homers and four walks. He’s 6-8 with an unsightly 6.39 ERA; his eight American League losses trail only former Royals Matt Harvey and Jorge Lopez, who have nine apiece for Baltimore.

Duffy was good for the two innings the Royals allowed him to pitch Wednesday— pitching his first game since May 12, he struck out four and didn’t give up a run. But for purposes of evaluating the KC rotation, Duffy’s two innings don’t count as a start.

The 3.2 frames Brady Singer threw in Tuesday night’s opener do, however. He struck out five but struggled, giving up a first-inning homer to Voit, another to Kyle Higashioka in the second, and walking the bases loaded in the fourth. He walked five in all.

KC eventually won, but Singer didn’t figure in the decision. He’s 3-5, 4.77 and has given up 32 runs in the first four innings of his 15 starts.

The Royals begin a three-game series at Texas tonight with Minor on the mound. Hopefully, he’ll jump start this troubled rota.

(Mandatory Credit: Jay Biggerstaff-USA TODAY Sports)
(Mandatory Credit: Jay Biggerstaff-USA TODAY Sports) /

The KC Royals need to make a decision about the status of Jorge Soler.

There seem to be no ends to the struggles of, or uncertainty surrounding, Jorge Soler. The most powerful Royal and smasher of the club’s single-season home run record just two seasons ago entered the New York series slashing .183/.283/.329, abominable numbers for a player whose primary talent and value are as a DH.

But the KC brass remains stubborn when it comes to Soler, and there he was starting in right field Tuesday night. After grounding out twice, he walked to lead off the seventh but left immediately for pinch runner Jarrod Dyson, a move that, even with the score tied 2-2, seemed a bit premature for a power hitter with a good chance to see another at-bat in a close game.

Perhaps the chance to score a run with the much speedier Dyson was more important, but pulling Soler might have been a tacit recognition that the KC Royals are losing, or should be losing, confidence in their slugger.

Manager Mike Matheny made the same move Wednesday night, but after Soler doubled in the eighth with KC leading by a run. But it was still slightly odd—there were two outs, so because Soler would have been running on contact, speed wasn’t as much a consideration as it may have been the night before.

Soler didn’t start in Thursday’s series finale, but Matheny handled him curiously again by pinch-hitting him for Nicky Lopez with one out in the ninth. It just didn’t make sense.

Lopez is on a tear and, at the moment Matheny pulled him back, was 1-for-2 with a single and a walk and hitting .346 for June; Soler was 1-for-6 in the series and batting .200 for the month, and is much slower than Lopez. Although Kansas City’s chances in the game—the Royals were behind 8-1—weren’t good, their odds to get a runner on were far better with Lopez.

Soler struck out on four pitches.

Now, the player KC traded Wade Davis for is slashing .182/.282/.327 and is the team’s biggest disappointment of the season. He hasn’t homered for two weeks. He last drove in a run 10 days ago, and it’s been almost six weeks since his average topped .200.

It’s time for the KC Royals to move on from Soler.

Next. Why did KC make this move?. dark

The KC Royals won a game in New York. Little else happened that was good.

Next