Let’s face it, as a team in last place, it’s difficult to justify the Royals getting more than one player into the All-Star Game. When Aaron Crow was named as a selection, it seemed like Alex Gordon‘s season had gone mostly unrecognized.
Meanwhile, Michael Cuddyer was selected from the Twins.
I don’t want to disparage Cuddyer’s season. His .286/.356/.459/.815 season is probably worthy of representing Minnesota, except that it’s not as good as Gordon’s .301/.368/.491/.859 line.
Gordon was snubbed in favor of Cuddyer, Tampa’s Matt Joyce, Chicago’s Carlos Quentin and Boston’s Jacoby Ellsbury. With nearly identical numbers (but more stolen bases) I can’t argue against Ellsbury, but here’s a comparison of the others in 2011 along with Gordon’s numbers:
It’s pretty close, and sure, both Joyce and Quentin are deserving based on their numbers. My argument is that Gordon has produced in every way possible. He gets on base, he scores runs, he drives in runs, he hits for power and hits for average. So does Joyce.
Quentin, though, is all-homer and not much else.
Outfield is always crowded at All-Star time, and considering the “every team gets a representative” rule, Cuddyer’s selection was what really hurt Alex. The Twins have been both awful offensively for most of the year, but their marquee players – Joe Mauer and Justin Morneau – have been injured for most of the season. Cuddyer’s been the most productive hitter they have.
But why not – and this is completely hypothetical – why not go with Scott Baker and his 105.1 innings of 3.15 ERA pitching? Choose him over Crow and Gordon over Cuddyer. It rewards both Baker for a solid season and Gordon for a superior season. Instead two players, though deserving (but not AS deserving as alternatives) make it in.
Going off of Baseball-Reference’s WAR calculations, Gordon and Joyce (2.9) lead Quentin’s 2.5 WAR. FanGraphs widens that gap, with Gordon’s 3.4 well above Joyce’s 2.4 and Quentin’s 2.2 WAR. The difference is Gordon’s defense. He leads the majors in assists and has just one error in the outfield.
Gordon at least made the ballot for voting for the final All-Star spot. He’s up against Paul Konerko, Adam Jones, Ben Zobrist and Victor Martinez. Konerko and Martinez are the favorites, but Kansas City has passionate fans all over.
So go vote for Alex. Voting is apparently unlimited so you can vote all day for him if you want. Let’s stuff the ballot box and get TWO Royals into the All-Star Game for the first time since 2003 (Mike Sweeney and Mike MacDougal).
Alex Gordon deserves to be an All-Star.